What is the median home value in Shelter Island (community), NY?

Name: Home values in Shelter Island (community), NY, 2020–2024
Creator: US Census Bureau
License: https://www.census.gov/data/developers/about/terms-of-service.html

The median value of owner-occupied homes in Shelter Island (community), NY is $1,025,400 (±$184,408), as owners estimated it in the Census Bureau’s 2020–2024 American Community Survey.

In Shelter Island (community), the median home value went from $778,400 in 2015–2019 to $1,025,400 in 2020–2024 (+31.7%).

Prices (CPI-U) rose 22.7% over the same years; the change is not measurably different from the rise in prices.

Figures last updated on November 12, 2026.

Median home value: $1,025,400 (±$184,408)
Owner-occupied homes: 610 (±177)
Most common range: $1,000,000 or more

Home values in Shelter Island (community)

Owner-occupied homes by value, 2020–2024
Value	Shelter Island (community)	Suffolk County	New York	United States
Less than $50,000	0.0% (±6.7 points)	1.6%	3.9%	5.3%
$50,000 to $99,999	3.3% (±3.7 points)	1.3%	5.6%	6.1%
$100,000 to $149,999	0.0% (±6.7 points)	0.9%	6.7%	6.8%
$150,000 to $199,999	0.0% (±6.7 points)	1.0%	8.3%	9.0%
$200,000 to $299,999	0.0% (±6.7 points)	3.6%	13.2%	17.8%
$300,000 to $499,999	11.5% (±18.2 points)	29.4%	19.7%	26.9%
$500,000 to $999,999	32.3% (±26.6 points)	51.4%	30.1%	20.9%
$1,000,000 or more	53.0% (±26.2 points)	10.6%	12.6%	7.1%

The most common range is $1,000,000 or more, 53.0% of owned homes.

Value is the owner’s own estimate of what the home and lot would sell for, not a sale price or an assessment.

Shelter Island (community) against Suffolk County, its state and the nation

Estimate (90% margin of error)
	Shelter Island (community)	Suffolk County	New York	United States
Median home value	$1,025,400 (±$184,408)	$578,400 (±$2,887)	$423,800 (±$1,627)	$332,700
Owner-occupied homes	610 (±177)	421,146 (±2,868)	4,196,985 (±19,607)	84,210,142

In Shelter Island (community), the median home value is higher than in Suffolk County ($578,400).

It is also higher than in New York ($423,800).

It is higher than the national figure ($332,700).

In Suffolk County, Shelter Island (community) ranks 12 of 111 places with a published estimate, from highest to lowest median home value.

Statewide, it ranks 19 of 403.

Rankings use the estimates alone; where margins of error overlap, neighboring ranks may not truly differ.

How home values in Shelter Island (community) have changed since 2015–2019

2015–2019 and 2020–2024 American Community Survey 5-year estimates
	2015–2019	2020–2024	Amount of change	Verdict
Median home value	$778,400 (±$112,227)	$1,025,400 (±$184,408)	+31.7%	No measurable change after inflation
Median owner cost with a mortgage	$2,362 (±$624)	$2,904 (±$291)	+22.9%	No measurable change after inflation
Median real estate taxes	$3,988 (±$529)	$4,174 (±$1,773)	+4.7%	No measurable change after inflation

The Census Bureau publishes 2015–2019 dollars in 2019 dollars and 2020–2024 dollars in 2024 dollars.

Prices (the CPI-U, US Bureau of Labor Statistics) rose 22.7% between 2019 and 2024, so a dollar figure’s verdict compares the two after raising the earlier one by that much, using the Census Bureau’s test for a difference.

The two periods do not overlap, as the Census Bureau recommends for 5-year estimates.

Median home value in places near Shelter Island (community)

Nearest places with a published estimate, compared with Shelter Island (community)
Place	Distance	Median home value	Compared with this place
Shelter Island (community)	—	$1,025,400 (±$184,408)	—
Village of North Haven	2.4 mi	$1,916,700 (±$597,013)	Higher
Shelter Island Heights	3.3 mi	$1,157,200 (±$153,275)	Not measurably different
Village of Sag Harbor	4.2 mi	$1,615,900 (±$587,215)	Not measurably different
Village of Greenport	4.9 mi	$961,200 (±$78,926)	Not measurably different
Northwest Harbor	4.9 mi	$1,573,300 (±$197,979)	Higher
Greenport West	5.2 mi	$839,900 (±$64,496)	Not measurably different
East Marion	5.9 mi	$857,800 (±$71,736)	Not measurably different
Noyack	5.9 mi	$1,085,500 (±$129,715)	Not measurably different

Nearby places with a measurably higher figure: Village of North Haven, NY ($1,916,700), Northwest Harbor, NY ($1,573,300).

Distance is measured in a straight line between the Census Bureau’s internal points for each place.

Median home value across Suffolk County, place by place

Rank	Place	Median home value
6	Montauk	$1,356,600 (±$243,422)
7	Shelter Island Heights	$1,157,200 (±$153,275)
8	North Sea	$1,128,000 (±$125,228)
9	Noyack	$1,085,500 (±$129,715)
10	East Hampton North	$1,077,000 (±$282,000)
11	Tuckahoe (community)	$1,075,500 (±$173,444)
12	Shelter Island (community)	$1,025,400 (±$184,408)
13	Westhampton	$1,018,200 (±$88,299)
14	Remsenburg-Speonk	$998,000 (±$129,830)
15	Orient	$973,700 (±$107,207)
16	Springs	$948,500 (±$77,639)
17	Dix Hills	$935,800 (±$23,787)
18	Cutchogue	$917,800 (±$91,957)

Showing 13 of 111 places in Suffolk County, ranked from highest to lowest.

Shelter Island (community) is a census-designated place: an unincorporated community the Census Bureau draws for statistics, with no municipal government of its own.

It lies inside the Town of Shelter Island, whose figures include it.

Survey years: 2020–2024 (American Community Survey 5-year estimates), compared with 2015–2019.

Margins of error are at the 90% confidence level.

What you can do on Seayora in Shelter Island (community)

One account for renting, owning, managing and fixing homes, with these figures beside you.

Own or manage a rental?

List it, sign the lease and collect rent online, with the figures for Shelter Island (community) beside you.

Create a landlord account · See what landlords get

Looking for a place to rent?

Browse homes for rent near Shelter Island (community), save the ones you like and apply online.

Browse rentals · Create a renter account

Do repairs, renovations or maintenance?

Get found by owners and renters near Shelter Island (community), and send estimates and invoices from your phone.

Join as a pro · Find a pro

Questions about Shelter Island (community)

What is the average home value in Shelter Island (community), NY?

The Census Bureau publishes the median: $1,025,400 (±$184,408) for owner-occupied homes in Shelter Island (community) (2020–2024 American Community Survey).

Have home values in Shelter Island (community) gone up?

In Shelter Island (community), the median home value went from $778,400 in 2015–2019 to $1,025,400 in 2020–2024 (+31.7%).

Prices (CPI-U) rose 22.7% over the same years; the change is not measurably different from the rise in prices.

Is this what homes in Shelter Island (community) sell for?

No: it is the value owners reported, which tends to lag the market; recent sale prices and an appraisal answer that question.

Sources

To check these figures in the Census Bureau’s own API, request the variables below from the 2024 ACS 5-year data profile (acs/acs5/profile) for Shelter Island CDP, New York (place:66828, in state:36).

Each estimate (E or PE) has a margin of error beside it (M or PM).

The 2015–2019 figures are B25077_001E, B25077_001M, B25088_002E, B25088_002M, B25103_001E, B25103_001M from the 2019 release.

The API needs a free key.

Request a Census API key.

DP04_0089E, DP04_0089M, DP04_0046E, DP04_0046M, DP04_0081PE, DP04_0081PM, DP04_0082PE, DP04_0082PM, DP04_0083PE, DP04_0083PM, DP04_0084PE, DP04_0084PM, DP04_0085PE, DP04_0085PM, DP04_0086PE, DP04_0086PM, DP04_0087PE, DP04_0087PM, DP04_0088PE, DP04_0088PM

This product uses the Census Bureau Data API but is not endorsed or certified by the Census Bureau.

Figures are published by the US Census Bureau, HUD, the Bureau of Labor Statistics and the FBI; Seayora reproduces them and does not adjust them, except where a sentence says it compares dollar figures after inflation. They describe the whole place, not any one building or street, and are not an appraisal, a rent determination, a tax bill, a safety rating or legal advice.