Who lives in the Town of Shelter Island, NY?

The median age of residents in the Town of Shelter Island, NY is 50.0 years, according to the US Census Bureau’s 2020–2024 American Community Survey.

It has an estimated 3,355 residents.

17.3% (±12.6 points) of residents are under 18.

36.1% (±13.9 points) of residents are 65 or older.

13.2% (±10.6 points) of residents were born outside the United States.

In the Town of Shelter Island, the median age went from 43.0 years in 2015–2019 to 50.0 years in 2020–2024 (7.0 years older), not a measurable change.

Figures last updated on .

Median age
50.0 years (±17.3)
Under 18
17.3%
65 and over
36.1%
Born outside the United States
13.2%

Age of residents in the Town of Shelter Island

Residents by age, 2020–2024
AgeTown of Shelter IslandSuffolk CountyNew YorkUnited States
Under 5 years8.0% (±7.3 points)5.3%5.4%5.6%
5 to 9 years2.7% (±2.7 points)5.4%5.5%6.0%
10 to 14 years4.8% (±4.5 points)6.2%5.9%6.4%
15 to 19 years6.4% (±5.0 points)6.5%6.1%6.6%
20 to 24 years2.7% (±4.0 points)6.4%6.3%6.5%
25 to 34 years0.1% (±0.2 points)12.2%14.2%13.7%
35 to 44 years21.8% (±10.8 points)12.0%13.0%13.2%
45 to 54 years7.9% (±5.1 points)13.2%12.2%12.2%
55 to 59 years6.0% (±4.3 points)7.8%6.7%6.2%
60 to 64 years3.5% (±4.7 points)7.2%6.7%6.4%
65 to 74 years24.4% (±10.6 points)10.3%10.3%10.2%
75 to 84 years10.7% (±6.9 points)5.4%5.3%5.1%
85 years and over1.0% (±1.8 points)2.2%2.2%1.9%

In the Town of Shelter Island, the median age is not measurably different from Suffolk County (41.7 years).

It is not measurably different from New York (39.8 years).

It is not measurably different from the national figure (38.9 years).

In Suffolk County, the Town of Shelter Island ranks 3 of 12 places with a published estimate, from highest to lowest median age.

Statewide, it ranks 216 of 1,004.

Rankings use the estimates alone; where margins of error overlap, neighboring ranks may not truly differ.

Households in the Town of Shelter Island

Estimate (90% margin of error)
Town of Shelter IslandSuffolk CountyNew YorkUnited States
Average household size2.41 (±0.46)2.93 (±0.01)2.49 (±0.01)2.53
Married-couple households46.5% (±16.7 points)56.1% (±0.5 points)42.5% (±0.2 points)46.9%
Households with children under 1814.3% (±10.2 points)30.8% (±0.4 points)27.3% (±0.1 points)29.5%
Households with someone 65 or older66.4% (±11.6 points)37.7% (±0.3 points)33.6% (±0.1 points)31.8%
Residents in the same home a year earlier96.1% (±4.0 points)92.8% (±0.3 points)90.1% (±0.1 points)87.7%

The average household in the Town of Shelter Island has 2.41 people.

In the Town of Shelter Island, the average household size is lower than in Suffolk County (2.93).

Where residents of the Town of Shelter Island were born and the languages they speak

Share of residents (languages: residents 5 and over), estimate (90% margin of error)
Town of Shelter IslandSuffolk CountyNew YorkUnited States
Born outside the United States13.2% (±10.6 points)16.8% (±0.3 points)22.8% (±0.1 points)14.1%
Speak a language other than English at home16.2% (±14.0 points)24.8% (±0.4 points)30.9% (±0.1 points)22.3%
Speak Spanish at home16.1% (±14.0 points)16.1% (±0.2 points)14.8% (±0.1 points)13.6%
Speak English less than “very well”9.2% (±8.2 points)9.7% (±0.2 points)13.6% (±0.1 points)8.6%

16.2% (±14.0 points) of residents 5 and over speak a language other than English at home.

In the Town of Shelter Island, the share of residents born outside the United States is not measurably different from Suffolk County (16.8%).

Veterans and disability in the Town of Shelter Island

Estimate (90% margin of error)
Town of Shelter IslandSuffolk CountyNew YorkUnited States
Civilian veterans (adults 18 and over)4.4% (±4.2 points)4.0% (±0.1 points)3.7% (±0.1 points)6.2%
Residents with a disability2.5% (±2.0 points)10.5% (±0.2 points)12.6% (±0.1 points)13.3%

In the Town of Shelter Island, the share of adults who are veterans is not measurably different from Suffolk County (4.0%).

In the Town of Shelter Island, the share of residents with a disability is lower than in Suffolk County (10.5%).

How the people of the Town of Shelter Island have changed since 2015–2019

2015–2019 and 2020–2024 American Community Survey 5-year estimates
2015–20192020–2024Amount of changeVerdict
Median age43.0 years (±11.5)50.0 years (±17.3)7.0 years olderNot a measurable change
Residents under 1826.2% (±11.6 points)17.3% (±12.6 points)−8.9 percentage pointsNot a measurable change
Residents 65 and over27.6% (±11.5 points)36.1% (±13.9 points)+8.5 percentage pointsNot a measurable change
Average household size2.23 (±0.26)2.41 (±0.46)+8.1%Not a measurable change
Born outside the United States10.3% (±4.7 points)13.2% (±10.6 points)+2.9 percentage pointsNot a measurable change
Speak a language other than English at home17.4% (±9.3 points)16.2% (±14.0 points)−1.2 percentage pointsNot a measurable change
Civilian veterans (adults 18 and over)15.9% (±8.1 points)4.4% (±4.2 points)−11.5 percentage pointsMeasurable decrease
Residents with a disability6.6% (±4.8 points)2.5% (±2.0 points)−4.1 percentage pointsNot a measurable change
Residents in the same home a year earlier99.4% (±0.9 points)96.1% (±4.0 points)−3.3 percentage pointsNot a measurable change

The two periods do not overlap, as the Census Bureau recommends for 5-year estimates.

Median age in places near the Town of Shelter Island

Nearest places with a published estimate, compared with the Town of Shelter Island
PlaceDistanceMedian ageCompared with this place
Town of Shelter Island—50.0 years (±17.3)—
Village of North Haven2.9 mi59.0 years (±2.4)Not measurably different
Village of Greenport3.5 mi51.1 years (±11.8)Not measurably different
Greenport West3.8 mi51.4 years (±5.7)Not measurably different
East Marion4.9 mi68.1 years (±7.5)Not measurably different
Town of Southold5.1 mi53.7 years (±3.3)Not measurably different
Village of Sag Harbor5.2 mi51.8 years (±7.7)Not measurably different
Southold (community)5.7 mi48.6 years (±7.4)Not measurably different
Noyack6.2 mi51.2 years (±10.0)Not measurably different

None of the nearby places differs measurably from this one on this figure.

Distance is measured in a straight line between the Census Bureau’s internal points for each place.

Median age across Suffolk County, place by place

RankPlaceMedian age
1Town of Southold53.7 years (±3.3)
2Town of Riverhead52.1 years (±2.1)
3Town of Shelter Island50.0 years (±17.3)
4Town of Southampton48.0 years (±1.6)
5Town of East Hampton46.3 years (±2.5)
6Town of Huntington46.0 years (±0.8)
7Town of Smithtown44.4 years (±0.7)
8Town of Brookhaven39.9 years (±0.5)
9Shinnecock Reservation39.8 years (±11.4)

Showing 9 of 12 places in Suffolk County, ranked from highest to lowest.

A New York town includes the villages and hamlets inside it, so the figures for the Town of Shelter Island include them.

The figures for the Town of Shelter Island include the places inside it that have pages of their own: Shelter Island (community), Shelter Island Heights.

Survey years: 2020–2024 (American Community Survey 5-year estimates), compared with 2015–2019.

Margins of error are at the 90% confidence level.

What you can do on Seayora in Town of Shelter Island

One account for renting, owning, managing and fixing homes, with these figures beside you.

Own or manage a rental?

List it, sign the lease and collect rent online, with the figures for Town of Shelter Island beside you.

Create a landlord account · See what landlords get

Looking for a place to rent?

Browse homes for rent near Town of Shelter Island, save the ones you like and apply online.

Browse rentals · Create a renter account

Do repairs, renovations or maintenance?

Get found by owners and renters near Town of Shelter Island, and send estimates and invoices from your phone.

Join as a pro · Find a pro

Questions about Town of Shelter Island

What is the median age in the Town of Shelter Island?

The median age of residents in the Town of Shelter Island, NY is 50.0 years (2020–2024 American Community Survey).

What share of people in the Town of Shelter Island are children or seniors?

17.3% of residents in the Town of Shelter Island are under 18 and 36.1% are 65 or older (2020–2024 American Community Survey).

How many people in the Town of Shelter Island were born in another country?

13.2% of residents in the Town of Shelter Island were born outside the United States, and 16.2% of residents 5 and over speak a language other than English at home.

How big is the average household in the Town of Shelter Island?

The average household in the Town of Shelter Island has 2.41 people.

What is the population of the Town of Shelter Island?

The Census Bureau estimates that 3,351 people lived in the Town of Shelter Island on July 1, 2025, up 113 from its April 2020 estimates base of 3,238 (3.5% more).

Is the Town of Shelter Island getting older?

In the Town of Shelter Island, the median age went from 43.0 years in 2015–2019 to 50.0 years in 2020–2024 (7.0 years older), not a measurable change.

Sources

This product uses the Census Bureau Data API but is not endorsed or certified by the Census Bureau.

Figures are published by the US Census Bureau, HUD, the Bureau of Labor Statistics and the FBI; Seayora reproduces them and does not adjust them, except where a sentence says it compares dollar figures after inflation. They describe the whole place, not any one building or street, and are not an appraisal, a rent determination, a tax bill, a safety rating or legal advice.

Figures last updated on .

Related