Payment Disputes & Chargebacks

What happens when a cardholder disputes a payment you received, and how to answer it in Seayora with the evidence already gathered.

Most payments go smoothly, but disputes happen. Here’s how they’re handled and what to expect.

Disputes between users

A disagreement about rent owed, a deposit deduction, or a job payment is between the two users involved — Seayora is not a party to the underlying transaction and does not adjudicate it, though records in the platform (payment history, messages, documents) can help resolve it.

Responding to a chargeback in Seayora

When a cardholder disputes a card payment you received, it appears under Payment disputes — Operations → Rent → Disputes on a landlord or management account, Finance for a contractor — on the website and in both phone apps. You are emailed straight away, and again 7, 3 and 1 days before the deadline and on the day it is due. A dispute nobody answers is decided for the cardholder.

  • What the cardholder says. Seayora reads the card network’s reason code and tells you the claim in plain words — they say they did not authorize it, that they were charged twice, that they canceled — and what the network asks a merchant to show for that kind of claim.
  • The evidence. Seayora gathers the records it already holds that answer the claim: the signed lease or invoice and its terms, how the payment was set up (a card the customer saved, automatic payment they turned on, or pressing Pay themselves), the customer’s earlier payments that were never disputed, their account and device history, the receipt they were sent and when they opened it, messages with them, proof the home was occupied or the job was done, refunds, and other charges around the same date. Each says Found, None on record, or Couldn’t check.
  • Your letter. A response letter is drafted from the reason code and the evidence you include, citing each record as a lettered exhibit. Edit it as you like — keep every fact to what an exhibit shows.
  • Your choice. Leave out any record you would not want the card issuer to read, add your own files (photos, a signed estimate — PDF, JPEG or PNG, up to 1 MB each), and contest only part of the amount if part of the claim is fair.
  • Sign and send. Preview the exact PDF, type your name under a statement that the response is true, and send. Seayora sends it to the payment processor, which forwards it to the card issuer. After it is sent it cannot be changed.

You can accept a dispute instead of answering it. Accepting means the cardholder keeps the money and the dispute fee is not refunded, and it cannot be undone — sometimes the honest answer, for example when the payment really was taken twice.

A question before a chargeback

American Express and Discover sometimes ask about a payment before opening a chargeback. Seayora shows this as a question from the bank: no money has moved, and a complete answer now usually ends it there. If it becomes a chargeback, the money is put on hold and you are told again.

Who can respond

The account that received the payment, and team members its owner has given “Take & refund payments”. Seayora staff can see a dispute to help you but cannot answer one for you — the response is a statement by your business, signed by a person at it. An assistant connected to your account can tell you which disputes need a response, but cannot answer or accept one.

The decision

The card issuer decides, usually within several weeks, and Seayora emails you the outcome. Seayora’s suggestions say what the card network asks for; they are not a prediction of the result. A decision can be overturned on appeal: if a dispute decided for the cardholder is later decided for you, the payment counts as paid again everywhere — a contractor’s receipt stands again and the customer is told, and a books invoice is paid again.

What you sent is kept with the dispute: the response PDF and your files, each with a fingerprint. The files themselves are deleted 180 days after the decision; the record of what was sent stays.

What the payment shows while it is disputed

The payment itself changes as the dispute moves, on the rent list, in your charge history and on your books invoices, so a disputed payment never reads as money you have.

DisputedThe cardholder’s bank has opened a dispute. The money is on hold with the bank while it decides.
Paid againThe dispute was decided in your favor and the money came back. Nothing else to do.
Charged backThe dispute was decided for the cardholder and the money went back to them. A rent payment reads as unpaid; a contractor receipt is marked reversed and your customer is told; a books invoice is reopened by the amount.
Returned by the bankA bank payment (ACH) was sent back by the payer’s bank, for example for insufficient funds or a closed account. It is not a dispute, and it is retried or handed to you depending on the reason.

The dispute fee

The payment processor charges a fixed fee for every dispute, and a smaller one for every returned bank payment. These are charged to the account that received the payment, itemized on your payments screen with what caused them, and deducted from your next payout before it leaves (Terms of Service § 9A). If a fee is listed as recorded but not yet being deducted, it is not taken from your payouts until that changes, and the payments screen says which.

Reducing dispute risk

Clear invoices, documented agreements, and prompt communication are the best defense — a payment with a matching invoice and a paper trail is far easier to defend than an undocumented one.

Frequently asked questions

How long does a chargeback take to resolve?

It depends on the card network and issuing bank, and can take several weeks. You’ll typically be notified of the outcome once the process concludes.

Can Seayora reverse a chargeback for me?

No — the decision belongs to the card network and issuing bank based on the evidence submitted. Seayora gathers your records, drafts the response and sends it on your signature, but doesn’t control the outcome.

How long do I have to respond?

The deadline is set by the card network and shown on the dispute — usually a couple of weeks from when it opens. Seayora reminds you 7, 3 and 1 days before it and on the day.

Can I change my response after sending it?

No. Once it reaches the payment processor it is forwarded to the card issuer as sent. Preview the PDF before you sign.

Does a chargeback mean the money is no longer owed?

A card issuer’s decision is about the card payment. If you believe the amount is still owed, you can contact the customer about paying another way.

Should I refund a payment proactively if there’s a dispute brewing?

It depends on the situation — sometimes a proactive refund resolves things faster and avoids a chargeback altogether, especially for a small, clearly justified amount. Use judgment based on the specific dispute.

Related guides

Related features and guides

  • Payment Disputes & Chargebacks — Feature. When a cardholder disputes a payment, Seayora explains the claim, gathers the records that answer it, drafts your response and sends it on your signature — on the web and in both apps.
  • Rent-Payment Credit Reporting — Documentation. Seayora reports rent to TransUnion — on-time months by default, and full payment history for residents who choose it or whose lease requires it. What counts as paid (Zelle matched to a bank account, cash recorded by the landlord with a receipt), the Rent Reporting Addendum, how a late month is confirmed and objected to, and how disputes, deaths and bankruptcies are handled.
  • Opening Your Payout Account — Documentation. The application that lets you be paid — what it asks for, what we fill in for you, what happens to your SSN and bank number, and how to answer when the processor asks for more.
  • Payment Plans for Rent You Cannot Pay in Full — Documentation. How a resident asks to spread a month’s rent — or is offered one — how the schedule can be shaped, how a landlord decides it, what the signed agreement says, when a date can be moved, and exactly what happens if an installment is missed.
  • Security Deposit Handling — Feature. Collect deposits through the platform, keep them tied to the lease and the unit, and back any deduction with dated move-in and move-out evidence.
  • AutoPay & Automated Rent Reminders — Feature. Tenants set up AutoPay once and rent drafts automatically on the due date written in the lease. Automated reminders go to anyone who is not on AutoPay.

Explore Seayora