Tenant Screening: What Landlords Need to Know
How to screen rental applicants fairly and legally: credit and background checks, consistent criteria, the FCRA’s adverse action notice and fair housing.
By Seayora Editorial Team · Published · Updated · Facts checked · 2 min read
Short answer: Screen every applicant against the same written criteria, get their written authorization before ordering a consumer report, and if you deny or condition an application because of a report, send an adverse action notice. The Fair Credit Reporting Act governs the report and the Fair Housing Act, plus state and city laws, govern what you may consider.
Good tenant screening helps you find reliable renters while treating every applicant fairly. Done wrong, it exposes you to legal risk.
What does tenant screening usually include?
- A credit report, to gauge financial reliability.
- A background check covering criminal and eviction history, where the law allows it.
- Income and employment verification. A common rule of thumb is income of about three times the monthly rent.
- Rental history and references from previous landlords.
Which laws apply?
A tenant screening report is a consumer report under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, which lets a landlord obtain one for a rental decision. If you take adverse action based on it, including denying the application or requiring a larger deposit or a co-signer, 15 U.S.C. § 1681m requires an adverse action notice that names the reporting agency and tells the applicant how to get a free copy and dispute it.
The Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status or disability. Many states and cities add more, including source of income: New York and New Jersey, for example, prohibit refusing an applicant because they pay with a housing voucher.
How do you keep screening fair and defensible?
- Write your criteria down and apply them to every applicant the same way.
- Get the applicant’s written authorization before ordering a report.
- Check your state and city for limits on criminal history, eviction records and application fees before you order.
- Keep each decision and the reason for it for at least two years (landlord recordkeeping).
Can you screen through Seayora?
Seayora’s applications are built around consistent criteria and compose the adverse action notice from the reasons you select. Screening reports themselves can be ordered only while a consumer reporting agency is connected; where none is, nothing can be ordered and no screening fee is charged, so run reports with an agency of your own and apply the same criteria to everyone. State application fee rules are published with their statutes.
Frequently asked questions
Can I reject an applicant for bad credit?
You can use credit as one criterion, applied to every applicant the same way. If you deny or condition an application based on a consumer report, you must send an adverse action notice under the FCRA.
What am I not allowed to ask?
Anything tied to a protected class under federal, state or city fair housing law. Focus on ability to pay and meet the lease terms, and check local rules, which often add protections such as source of income.
State-by-state rules
- How much can a landlord charge for a rental application fee? — compared across 16 states and the District of Columbia
- Can a landlord refuse a Section 8 voucher? — compared across 29 states and the District of Columbia
Sources
- 15 U.S.C. § 1681b, Permissible purposes of consumer reports, Legal Information Institute
- 15 U.S.C. § 1681m, Requirements on users of consumer reports, Legal Information Institute
- Fair Housing Act overview, U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development
- Regulation V (12 CFR Part 1022), Fair Credit Reporting, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
How Seayora helps
FCRA tools: Applications with consistent criteria and adverse action notices composed for you.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Landlord-tenant law varies by state and city and changes often, so check the current rule for your property and talk to an attorney before acting on a dispute.
How we write and check these guides: editorial standards.
Related on Seayora
- FCRA Adverse Action Notices: What Landlords Must Tell Applicants — Guide. When a screening report leads you to deny an applicant or ask for more, the Fair Credit Reporting Act requires a notice. What it must say, with the statute.
- Criminal Background Checks for Renters: Fair Chance Laws in 2026 — Guide. When a landlord may use an applicant’s criminal record: assisted-housing rules, the FCRA, and fair chance laws in NJ, NYC, DC, Maryland and Cook County.
- FCRA-Compliant Screening — Feature. Tenant screening built to FCRA requirements, including secure applicant-entered data and adverse-action support when you decline an applicant.
- Tenant Screening & Background Checks — Documentation. Screening is not available yet — no consumer reporting agency is connected and no fee is charged. How it will work, and the FCRA responsibilities that come with it.
- Rental Applications — Documentation. How online rental applications work on Seayora — what applicants submit, how landlords review, and how to keep the process fair and consistent.
- Fair Housing Support — Feature. Structured applications, consistent screening criteria, automated policy application, and listing guidance that supports fair housing compliance.