Only Detroit Meets the 1% Rule Among Large US Cities

Census figures for 323 US cities of 100,000 or more: at median rents and home values only Detroit meets the 1% rule, and 57 cities are under 0.3%.

By Seayora Editorial Team · Published · Facts checked · 2 min read

Short answer: At median rents and median home values, only one US city of 100,000 or more people meets the 1% rule: Detroit, where a month’s median gross rent is 1.28% of the median home value. That is from the Census Bureau’s 2020–2024 American Community Survey for 323 large cities with reliable estimates. Four cities reach 0.8%, eleven reach 0.7%, and 57, most of them in California, are under 0.3%.

Key takeaways

  • Only Detroit meets the 1% rule at median figures among 323 large US cities.
  • Jackson, Mississippi (0.94%), Cleveland (0.93%) and Dayton (0.91%) come next.
  • Seventy-nine of the 323 cities reach 0.5%; 57 are under 0.3%, most of them in California.
  • The 1% rule ignores every cost of owning a property, so these figures are a screen, not a return.

Which large US cities meet the 1% rule?

Only Detroit, at median figures. The 1% rule is the rule of thumb that a rental’s monthly rent should be at least 1% of its price. Dividing each city’s median monthly gross rent by its median home value, Detroit comes to 1.28%, with a median rent of $1,074 against a median home value of $83,900. No other city of 100,000 or more with reliable Census estimates reaches 1%.

Median monthly gross rent as a share of median home value, US cities of 100,000 or more, Census Bureau ACS 2020–2024.
CityMonthly rent as a share of home value
Detroit, Michigan1.28%
Jackson, Mississippi0.94%
Cleveland, Ohio0.93%
Dayton, Ohio0.91%
Toledo, Ohio0.79%

Where is the ratio lowest?

In the San Francisco Bay Area. Berkeley (0.15%), Sunnyvale (0.17%), San Francisco (0.18%), San Mateo (0.19%) and Santa Clara (0.19%) have the lowest ratios of the 323 cities, and 57 cities in all are under 0.3%, most of them in California, where home values are high relative to rents.

How common is a ratio of 0.5% or more?

Seventy-nine of the 323 cities reach 0.5%, eleven reach 0.7% and four reach 0.8%. The middle city’s gross rent yield, a year of median rent divided by the median home value, is 4.8%, or 0.4% a month. The full ranking, with the margin of error for every city, is on Seayora’s best places to buy rental property page.

How the figures were made

The figures are the Census Bureau’s American Community Survey 2020–2024 5-year estimates of median gross rent and median home value for every incorporated city of 100,000 or more people. A city was left out if either estimate was top-coded or had a coefficient of variation over 30%. The ratio compares the median rent of rented homes with the median value of owner-occupied homes, which are often different homes, and it leaves out taxes, insurance, vacancy, repairs and financing (Census Bureau).

What the 1% rule leaves out

Property taxes, insurance, vacancy, repairs, management and the mortgage all come out of the rent before an owner sees a return. A property that clears the 1% rule can still lose money, and one that misses it can earn a steady return. The rental property calculator and the cap rate calculator take the costs into account.

Frequently asked questions

Does any big city meet the 1% rule?

At median rents and home values, only Detroit among US cities of 100,000 or more, at 1.28%, in the Census Bureau’s 2020–2024 figures.

What is a typical rent-to-price ratio in large US cities?

The middle city’s monthly median rent is about 0.4% of its median home value, a gross rent yield of 4.8% a year.

Is the 1% rule still realistic?

At median prices in large cities, rarely. Some individual properties still meet it, but the rule is a quick screen that leaves out every cost of owning a rental.

Sources

  1. American Community Survey 2020–2024 5-year estimates, tables DP04 and DP05, US Census Bureau

How Seayora helps

Best places to buy rental property: Gross rent yield for 323 large US cities, ranked, with margins of error.

How we write and check these guides: editorial standards.

Related on Seayora

Explore Seayora