New York Warranty of Habitability: RPL § 235-b Explained
Every New York lease, written or oral, promises a home fit to live in, and a tenant cannot waive it. What RPL § 235-b covers and what a tenant can do.
By Seayora Editorial Team · Published · Facts checked · 4 min read
Short answer: Under New York Real Property Law § 235-b, every written or oral residential lease carries a promise that the home and the common areas are fit to live in and free of conditions dangerous to the occupants’ life, health or safety. A tenant cannot waive it, and it does not cover a condition the tenant caused. When a landlord breaches it, a tenant can seek a rent reduction in court, and a rent-regulated tenant can also file a rent-reduction complaint with DHCR.
Key takeaways
- It is part of every residential lease in New York, written or oral, and covers the common areas as well as the apartment.
- A lease clause that waives or narrows it is void.
- A condition caused by the tenant, or by people under the tenant’s control, is not a breach.
- The remedy is usually a rent reduction measured by what the apartment was worth without the missing services; the landlord must have known, or should have known, about the problem.
What does the warranty of habitability promise?
Real Property Law § 235-b says that in every written or oral lease or rental agreement for residential premises, the landlord is deemed to promise that the premises, and all areas used in common with other tenants, are fit for human habitation and for the uses the parties reasonably intended, and that the occupants will not be subjected to conditions that are dangerous, hazardous or detrimental to their life, health or safety (RPL § 235-b). A condition caused by the misconduct of the tenant, or of people under the tenant’s direction or control, is not a breach.
The Attorney General gives examples of a breach: not providing heat or hot water on a regular basis, or not ridding an apartment of an insect infestation (NY Attorney General). In New York City, the heating rules set the temperatures; see NYC heat rules.
Can a lease waive it?
No. Any agreement by a tenant waiving or modifying these rights is void as contrary to public policy (RPL § 235-b(2)).
Who can rely on it?
| Occupant | Can raise the warranty? |
|---|---|
| Tenant or subtenant of a rental apartment | Yes |
| Tenant or subtenant in a co-op or condo building | Yes |
| Owner of a cooperative apartment | Yes |
| Owner of a condominium unit | No |
What can a tenant do when the landlord breaches it?
- Sue for a rent reduction. A court can grant one if it finds the landlord violated the warranty.
- If the apartment is rent regulated, file a rent-reduction complaint with the Division of Housing and Community Renewal (DHCR). The tenant must first write to the landlord about the problem, and the complaint can be filed no sooner than 10 days and no later than 60 days after that notice was sent.
- Withhold rent, with a risk: the landlord may sue for nonpayment, and the tenant then raises the breach as a counterclaim.
- In extenuating circumstances, make a necessary repair and deduct its reasonable cost from the rent — for example, a broken door lock the landlord was told about and willfully left unrepaired. Keep the receipts and every message about the repair.
- If the apartment becomes uninhabitable because of a fire or other damage the tenant did not cause, and the lease does not say otherwise, leave and cancel the lease, owing no further rent (Real Property Law § 227).
All five are as the Attorney General describes them (NY Attorney General). Withholding rent and deducting repairs carry the most risk; free legal services may be available to tenants who qualify, and the Attorney General’s page lists them.
How is a rent reduction worked out?
The reduction is the actual rent minus the estimated value of the apartment without the essential services, and the landlord must have had actual or constructive notice of the defect (NY Attorney General). The statute lets the court set the damages without expert testimony; limits recovery for a breach caused by a strike the landlord did not cause, to the landlord’s net savings from it, if the landlord made a good-faith attempt to cure it; and, for a rent-regulated apartment, subtracts any rent reduction DHCR has already ordered for the same problem (RPL § 235-b(3)).
What it means for a landlord
Because notice decides whether a reduction is owed, the record of when a problem was reported and when it was fixed matters as much as the repair. A repair request in Seayora is a dated work order with its messages, photos and completion attached to the unit, which is the record both sides can point to.
Frequently asked questions
Does the warranty of habitability apply to an oral lease in New York?
Yes. RPL § 235-b applies to every written or oral lease or rental agreement for residential premises.
Can I withhold rent in New York for repairs?
A tenant may, but the landlord can then sue for nonpayment and the tenant has to prove the breach as a counterclaim. A rent-reduction lawsuit or, for a regulated apartment, a DHCR complaint carries less risk.
Does it cover hallways and other common areas?
Yes. The statute covers all areas used in common with other tenants, not only the apartment.
Do condo owners have a warranty of habitability?
No. Owners of cooperative apartments can raise it, but owners of condominium units cannot; tenants and subtenants in both kinds of building can.
Sources
- Real Property Law § 235-b, Warranty of habitability, New York State Senate (Open Legislation)
- Legal services and code enforcement: Habitability and repairs, New York State Attorney General
How Seayora helps
Maintenance requests: Every repair request is a dated work order with photos and messages, kept with the unit.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Landlord-tenant law varies by state and city and changes often, so check the current rule for your property and talk to an attorney before acting on a dispute.
How we write and check these guides: editorial standards.
Related on Seayora
- Rent Withholding Laws by State: When Tenants Can Withhold Rent — Guide. When a tenant may withhold rent or pay it into escrow over repairs, with the notice and conditions in each of the 19 states with a statute.
- How to Break a Lease in New York City: Your Legal Options — Guide. Breaking a lease in New York: the landlord’s duty to re-rent, and the early exits for domestic violence, tenants 62 or older, and military service.
- RPL § 226-c: New York Rent Increase Notice (30, 60 or 90 Days) — Guide. A New York landlord raising rent 5% or more, or not renewing, must give 30, 60 or 90 days’ written notice depending on how long the tenant has lived there.
- Good Cause Eviction in New York City — coverage, the local rent standard and the notice — Documentation. Which of your NYC units the Good Cause Eviction law covers, the exemptions and how each is decided, the highest presumptively reasonable rent increase, and the § 231-c notice every lease and renewal must carry.
- Compliance Alerts & Required Filings — Feature. Seayora watches your properties for new violations and works out which recurring filings each building owes, turns both into a dated checklist, and emails you when something new appears. Live violation data for New York City; rule-based filing obligations across the NYC metro.
- The FARE Act fee disclosure — every fee itemized, checked and signed before the lease — Documentation. Under New York City's FARE Act the landlord gives a new tenant an itemized list of every fee and the tenant signs it before the lease. Seayora checks each fee against the FARE Act and New York's caps, refuses to send one the law forbids, and keeps the signed copy.