How to Find Good Tenants: Listing, Screening and Fair Housing

How to find good tenants: a clear listing, fair written criteria, a full application, verified income and references, and a lease that sets expectations.

By Seayora Editorial Team · Published · Facts checked · 2 min read

Short answer: You find good tenants by attracting many qualified applicants and choosing among them fairly: a clear, honest listing with good photos and the rent and requirements stated up front; written screening criteria applied to everyone; a complete application with consent; verified income and landlord references; and a clear lease. Good tenants are usually the ones who pay on time, look after the home and communicate, so look for evidence of those things rather than impressions, and never use a protected characteristic.

Key takeaways

  • A clear listing with the rent, fees and requirements attracts qualified applicants.
  • Write your criteria first and apply them to everyone.
  • Verify income and call previous landlords.
  • Never state or act on a preference based on a protected class.

Where do you find good tenants?

  • Listing sites, with complete details and real photos; on Seayora a listing advertises free for its first 60 days.
  • Referrals from current tenants, neighbors and local employers.
  • A sign at the property, for people who already want the neighborhood.
  • University housing offices and relocation services, where relevant.

How do you screen for a good tenant?

  1. Publish criteria before you show the home: income, rental history, credit and any occupancy limit.
  2. Collect a complete application from every adult, with consent to verify.
  3. Verify income; our guide on how landlords verify income lists the documents.
  4. Call previous landlords and ask factual questions about payment and the condition of the home.
  5. Run any credit or background check consistently and lawfully; see how to run a credit check.
  6. Decide by the criteria, and record why.

What makes a good tenant?

Evidence of the things that matter to a tenancy: steady income for the rent, a history of paying on time, good references from past landlords, care for previous homes, and clear communication during the application. Judge evidence, not impressions.

What should you never say in a rental ad?

Federal law makes it unlawful to publish any notice, statement or advertisement that indicates a preference, limitation or discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin (24 CFR 100.75). Describe the home, not the tenant you want: "two bedrooms near the train" rather than "ideal for a young professional couple". Our guide on how to advertise a rental property has more examples.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best way to find tenants?

A complete, honest listing on sites renters use, plus referrals, with your rent and requirements stated up front so applicants self-select.

Can I choose a tenant I like better?

You can choose by legitimate, consistently applied criteria such as income, references and rental history, but not by any protected characteristic.

How do I find tenants for my rental property fast?

Price it at the market rate, list it with good photos everywhere renters look, answer inquiries quickly and offer viewings soon after.

Sources

  1. 24 CFR 100.75, Discriminatory advertisements, statements and notices, Electronic Code of Federal Regulations

How Seayora helps

Creating a listing: A listing with photos and requirements, free to advertise for its first 60 days.

How we write and check these guides: editorial standards.

Related on Seayora

  • How to Deny a Rental Application Legally (With a Template) — Guide. How landlords should decline a rental application: written criteria, the adverse action notice when a report was used, what to say and what to keep.
  • How to Accept Rental Applications Online (2026): Fair and Fast — Guide. How landlords take rental applications online: what to ask, the same criteria for everyone, application fees, the adverse action notice, and records to keep.
  • Questions to Ask Prospective Tenants (and What Not to Ask) — Guide. The questions landlords can ask prospective tenants about move-in, income, rental history and pets, and the questions fair housing law makes off-limits.
  • Fair Housing Support — Feature. Structured applications, consistent screening criteria, automated policy application, and listing guidance that supports fair housing compliance.
  • Online Rental Applications — Feature. Collect complete rental applications online and track every applicant in one pipeline, with the same questions and the same criteria for everybody. Screening reports are not available through Seayora yet — no consumer reporting agency is connected — so nothing is ordered and no screening fee is charged.
  • Rental Criteria: Publish What Applicants Are Held To — Documentation. Set the income, credit, rental-history, eviction, occupancy and guarantor criteria for your homes once, publish them on each listing before anybody applies, and let renters check their own numbers — with the law of each home's place folded in.

Explore Seayora