How to Deny a Rental Application Legally (With a Template)
How landlords should decline a rental application: written criteria, the adverse action notice when a report was used, what to say and what to keep.
By Seayora Editorial Team · Published · Facts checked · 2 min read
Short answer: To deny a rental application legally, decide by written screening criteria you apply to every applicant, never by a protected characteristic, and tell the applicant promptly in writing. If anything in a credit or background report contributed to the decision, the Fair Credit Reporting Act requires an adverse action notice naming the reporting agency and explaining the applicant’s right to a free copy and to dispute it. Keep the application, the criteria and your reasons on file, and return any refundable fee or deposit as the law requires.
Key takeaways
- Decide by written criteria applied to everyone.
- Tell the applicant in writing, promptly and politely.
- If a consumer report played a part, send an adverse action notice.
- Never base a denial on a protected characteristic.
- Keep the file and return refundable money as required.
Can a landlord deny a rental application?
Yes, for legitimate reasons tied to the tenancy, such as insufficient income, unverifiable or poor rental history, or incomplete or false information, judged against criteria applied to every applicant. Fair housing law forbids denying because of race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status or national origin, and many states and cities add more protected classes, such as source of income.
What must a denial include if you used a screening report?
If a consumer report (credit, eviction or criminal history from a screening company) contributed to the denial, or to requiring a co-signer or higher deposit, you must notify the applicant, give the name and contact details of the agency that supplied the report, state that the agency did not make the decision, and explain their right to a free copy and to dispute inaccurate information (15 U.S.C. § 1681m). Some cities and states add their own notice rules for criminal history.
How do you politely decline a rental applicant?
- Thank them for applying.
- Say the application was not approved, in plain words.
- If a report was used, include the required adverse action notice.
- Explain any refund of fees or deposits and when it will arrive.
- Keep the message factual; do not argue the decision or mention anything personal.
What records should a landlord keep after a denial?
The application, your written criteria, how the applicant measured against them, any notices sent and when, and any refund. Consistent records are your best defense if a decision is ever questioned. Our guide to questions to ask prospective tenants covers what not to ask in the first place, and how to run a credit check covers consent.
Frequently asked questions
Do landlords have to tell you why you were denied?
If a consumer report contributed, they must send an adverse action notice. Some states and cities require more; many landlords give the reason anyway.
Can a landlord deny an application without a reason?
A landlord can decline based on legitimate criteria, but never for a protected characteristic, and must give the FCRA notice if a report was used.
Do I have to refund the application fee if I deny someone?
It depends on your state; some require refunds if no screening was done or limit fees. Check the application fee rules for your state.
State-by-state rules
- How much can a landlord charge for a rental application fee? — compared across 16 states and the District of Columbia
Sources
- 15 U.S.C. § 1681m, Requirements on users of consumer reports, Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
How Seayora helps
Rental applications: Every applicant on the same form, with decisions recorded in one place.
How we write and check these guides: editorial standards.
Related on Seayora
- FCRA Adverse Action Notices: What Landlords Must Tell Applicants — Guide. When a screening report leads you to deny an applicant or ask for more, the Fair Credit Reporting Act requires a notice. What it must say, with the statute.
- How to Accept Rental Applications Online (2026): Fair and Fast — Guide. How landlords take rental applications online: what to ask, the same criteria for everyone, application fees, the adverse action notice, and records to keep.
- Tenant Screening: What Landlords Need to Know — Guide. How to screen rental applicants fairly and legally: credit and background checks, consistent criteria, the FCRA’s adverse action notice and fair housing.
- FCRA-Compliant Screening — Feature. Tenant screening built to FCRA requirements, including secure applicant-entered data and adverse-action support when you decline an applicant.
- Online Rental Applications — Feature. Collect complete rental applications online and track every applicant in one pipeline, with the same questions and the same criteria for everybody. Screening reports are not available through Seayora yet — no consumer reporting agency is connected — so nothing is ordered and no screening fee is charged.
- Fair Housing Support — Feature. Structured applications, consistent screening criteria, automated policy application, and listing guidance that supports fair housing compliance.